The world is constantly evolving, and the field of transcription is no exception.

Transcription requires a great deal of focus, attention to detail, and accuracy.

Technology has come a long way in recent years, and we now have access to Artificial Intelligence (AI) transcription software that can automatically transcribe recordings.

However, the question that arises is, which one is better, AI transcription or human transcription?

As you are about to see, there are several key factors for you to consider.

The Importance of Accurate Transcription

Accurate transcription is a crucial aspect when it comes to record management.

It involves transcribing audio and video recordings into written documents that can be easily accessible and understood.

The significance of accurate transcription cannot be overstated especially in professions such as medical, legal, and research.

In the medical field, incorrect information can have disastrous consequences.

Accurate transcription of medical records, which include medical histories, physical exams, and test results, is necessary for appropriate diagnosis and treatment of patients.

It ensures that medical practitioners have complete information about a patient’s medical condition, medication allergies, and treatment plans.

Any error in transcription can lead to misdiagnosis or even cause permanent complications.

Moreover, accurate transcription of medical records is vital for legal and insurance purposes.

These documents serve as evidence that can be used in support of a medical claim.

In a court of law, the accuracy of a medical transcription can be the difference between winning or losing a case.

In the legal field, transcripts serve as an essential reference point for any court case.

Whether in the recording of deposition testimony, court hearings, or trials, transcripts are necessary for preparing legal briefs and providing an accurate account of courtroom proceedings.

Accurate transcription ensures that all parties involved can review and reference the same information, which mitigates any misinterpretation or misunderstanding.

Moreover, in the legal field, missed deadlines and court filings due to erroneous transcription can cause significant legal troubles.

Inaccurate information can lead to the dismissal of a case or even a lawsuit for malpractice or negligence.

Accurate transcription is therefore crucial in the legal field, where even the slightest error can cause irreparable damage.

Research is a vital aspect of discovery and progress, which means accurate transcription of research findings, interviews, and observation data ensures that the information is reliable and trustworthy.

Professional and educational researchers depend heavily on accurate transcription that is free of transcription errors.

Inaccurate transcription of research results can lead to a skewed analysis of data, ultimately undermining the research’s credibility.

A study that has been rendered untrustworthy due to flawed transcription undermines the researcher’s efforts.

In research studies, accuracy is the cornerstone that determines the success or failure of any particular study.

Accuracy Comparison: AI Transcription vs. Human Transcription

AI transcription software uses natural language processing (NLP) algorithms and machine learning models to transcribe audio or video files into text rapidly.

AI transcriptions are produced in a matter of minutes, and the accuracy of these transcripts depends on various factors such as the quality of the audio and the complexity of the language used.

The accuracy of the transcription is dependent on the quality of the audio file.

If the audio is clear with no background noise, the AI transcription software produces highly accurate transcripts with an error rate of fewer than 5%.

Conversely, if the audio quality is poor, the accuracy rate of AI transcription takes a dip, leading to errors in transcripts.

The challenge is, very few audio files we receive from clients have the level of clarity that would work well with an AI app.

Human transcription, on the other hand, involves a person listening to an audio or video file and transcribing it into a written document.

A human transcriptionist can handle varying quality of the audio and will put in contextual knowledge to derive more accuracy.

In terms of accuracy, human transcription is generally more reliable, given that a human being can discern nuances and contextual knowledge that AI might miss.

Limitations of AI Transcription: What it Still Struggles with

Artificial Intelligence (AI) transcription has been gaining popularity in recent years due to its accuracy, efficiency, and cost-effectiveness.

It has proven to be a valuable tool for a wide range of industries, from healthcare to marketing.

However, despite its many benefits, AI transcription is not yet perfect.

There are still some limitations that it struggles with.

One of the most significant limitations of AI transcription is its inability to accurately transcribe accents and dialects.

AI systems are trained on data sets that are primarily composed of standard English.

As a result, any deviation from this standard can cause errors in the transcription.

Accents and dialects can be challenging for AI to decipher, leading to inaccuracies in the final output.

Another limitation of AI transcription is its inability to effectively eliminate background noise.

Human transcribers can often distinguish between different sources of sound and filter out irrelevant noise.

However, AI systems struggle with this task, especially in environments with high levels of background noise.

This can lead to inaccurate transcriptions, as the AI system may not be able to distinguish between the speaker’s voice and other sounds in the environment.

AI transcription also struggles with contextual understanding.

Human transcribers can recognize when a speaker is joking, being sarcastic, or using metaphors.

However, AI systems have difficulty in understanding these nuances.

As a result, they can misinterpret the meaning of a conversation, leading to inaccurate transcriptions.

Homophones and homonyms are words that sound the same but have different meanings.

These words can be problematic for AI transcription, as they can be difficult to distinguish in the absence of contextual clues.

For example, the words ‘write’ and ‘right’ sound the same but have different meanings.

Human transcribers can easily distinguish between these two words based on the context of the conversation, but AI systems struggle with this task, leading to inaccuracies in the transcription.

Finally, AI transcription struggles with speaker identification, especially in conversations with multiple speakers.

Speaker identification is essential for accurate transcriptions, as it allows the AI system to attribute the correct content to the right speaker.

However, distinguishing between speakers can be challenging for AI systems, especially when there are multiple speakers talking at the same time.

This can lead to inaccuracies in the transcription, as the system may attribute the wrong content to the wrong speaker.

Conclusion: Human Transcription Wins!

AI transcription has come a long way in recent years, but it still has some limitations.

While AI transcription is an efficient and cost-effective tool, it simply does not compare to the capability and quality of human transcribers.

As technology continues to advance, we may see these limitations to be addressed in the future, leading to even more accurate and reliable transcription services.

However, until then, it is important to be aware of these limitations and to use  human transcribers to ensure the most accurate final output.

Businesses love our fast, affordable, and accurate transcriptions.

Our smart verbatim audio transcripts include what you say – minus ums, uhs, filler words, and stutters.

To order your professional transcript now, click here to get started.